Don’t Eat Santa
There is a game that has been quietly stealing the show at family Christmases for years, and it needs almost nothing: a tray, a grid of Santa pictures, a handful of small treats, and one person willing to leave the room. It is called Don’t Eat Santa, and the reason children beg to play it five times in a row is the delicious tension of it. You are eating treats, one by one, in front of an audience that knows something you do not — and at any second, the whole room is going to erupt.
It is a perfect Christmas game for the exact moment when the presents are done, the food is settling, and the children are starting to bounce off the walls. It takes two minutes to set up, a round lasts about three minutes, and it works just as well on a kitchen table as it does on the living room floor. No screens, no batteries, no complicated rules to explain. Just Santa, some sweets, and a room full of people trying very hard not to give the secret away.

At a Glance
- Players: 3 to 12 (best with 4 to 8)
- Ages: 4 and up; adults enjoy it just as much as children
- Time needed: 2 minutes to set up, about 3 minutes per round, and you will play at least five rounds
- What you need: a Santa picture grid, one small treat per picture, and a tray or table to play on
- Best for: family Christmas Day, Christmas Eve, classroom parties, kids’ Christmas parties, and any gathering with children under twelve
What You Need
The Santa grid. The game is played on a grid of Santa pictures — usually twelve or sixteen squares, each with a different Santa face, a Santa hat, a reindeer, a present, or another Christmas picture. You can make one in about ten minutes: draw a grid on a large sheet of paper or card and sketch or stick a different Santa picture in each square. Old Christmas cards are perfect for this — cut out the Santas and glue one into each square. If you have a printer, print a grid of Santa clip-art images. The pictures do not need to be beautiful; children genuinely do not care. They need to be different enough from each other that the players can say “the one with the big beard” or “the one by the chimney” and everyone knows which square they mean.
Sixteen squares is the sweet spot. Fewer than twelve and the game ends too fast; more than twenty and the eater gets full before the round ends, and younger children lose track of which squares are left. A four-by-four grid on a sheet of card, covered with a tray or a tea towel when it is not in use, will survive a whole Christmas and can be brought out again next year.
The treats. One small treat per square. The classic choice is small wrapped sweets, mini chocolate Santas, or little biscuits — things that can be eaten in one bite. Wrapped sweets are the most practical because they survive being handled and they do not melt on warm fingers. Avoid anything sticky, anything that needs a plate, and anything large: the eater may have to eat six or seven treats in a single round, so small is essential. For children with allergies, use the treats they can eat, and keep the game treats in a separate, clearly marked bowl from the start.
A tray or a clear table. A large tray is ideal because you can carry the whole game into the room like a grand reveal, and you can lift it away between rounds. A baking tray works perfectly. If you are playing on the floor, a tea towel under the grid stops it sliding around.

How to Play
Lay the Santa grid on the tray and put one treat on every square, so each Santa has a treat sitting on top of him. Choose one player to be the eater. That player leaves the room — properly leaves, out of earshot, door closed — while everyone else picks the secret Santa.
While the eater is out of the room, the remaining players point together, quietly, at one square on the grid. That square is Santa. It is the one square the eater must not eat. Everyone agrees, everyone remembers which one it is, and then someone calls the eater back in. This is the moment the giggling usually starts, and it is the hardest part of the game for young children, who are terrible at keeping a straight face. That is fine. It is most of the fun.
The eater returns and starts eating the treats, one at a time, in any order they like. They pick a square, pick up the treat, and eat it. If it is not Santa, everyone stays quiet — or says something encouraging and entirely unhelpful, like “good choice!” or “ooh, that one!” The eater picks another, and another. With every safe treat, the tension climbs, because the odds are getting worse. The squares are disappearing and Santa is still out there somewhere.
Then, eventually, the eater reaches for the treat on the secret Santa square. The moment their fingers touch it, the whole room shouts: “Don’t eat Santa!”
That is the end of the round. The eater puts the treat back, everyone laughs, and the grid is reset for the next round. The player who shouted loudest — or the youngest player, or the next person in the circle — becomes the eater, and it starts again.
There are two small rules worth agreeing before the first round. First, the eater may not be told anything — no hints, no warnings, no meaningful looks. The only words allowed from the audience are the shout at the end. Second, the secret Santa must be chosen again for every round, and it should not be the same square twice in a row, or the eater will work it out from last time.
Why Children Love It So Much
It is worth understanding why this simple game lands so hard with children, because it helps you run it well. First, the eater is the centre of attention in a safe, happy way — everyone is watching them, but everyone is on their side. Second, the secret is a shared one: the children who are not eating get to be in on the secret together, which feels conspiratorial and grown-up. Third, the game is over quickly and resets instantly, so nobody has to wait long for their turn. And fourth, there are sweets. Never underestimate the sweets.
It also works beautifully for mixed ages because the game is the same whether you are four or forty. Grandparents make wonderful eaters — they ham it up, they pretend to reach for one square and grab another, and children love watching an adult be the one who does not know the secret for once. If you have a shy child who does not want to be the eater, let them be the one who picks the secret Santa instead. It is a starring role too, and it keeps them in the game.
Tips for Running It Well
Reset fast. The gap between rounds is where children lose interest. While one round is ending, have the next eater already chosen and the treats already counted out. A smooth reset keeps the energy up and lets you squeeze in twice as many rounds.
Use a mix of treats. Not every square needs the same treat. Put a mini chocolate on some squares, a wrapped sweet on others, and a biscuit on a few. It gives the eater something to think about — do they go for the chocolate first, or save it? — and it stops the game from feeling like eating the same thing twelve times.
Make the shout a real event. The shout of “Don’t eat Santa!” is the payoff of the whole game, so let it be loud. Encourage everyone to shout it together, on the same beat, the instant the eater touches the treat. Some families add a rule that the eater has to freeze like a statue when they hear it. Theatrics are welcome.
Play it after the main meal, not before. A game built entirely on eating small treats works best when nobody is hungry enough to eat the whole grid in thirty seconds, and when the treats are a bonus rather than a meal. Christmas afternoon, between presents and the evening film, is the perfect slot.
Keep a spare grid. The original will get sticky. If you are playing with a big group or over several days of Christmas, make two grids at the start and keep one in reserve. Ten minutes of preparation saves you from a soggy, chocolate-smeared grid on Boxing Day.
Variations to Try
Don’t Eat Rudolph. The same game with a reindeer grid. Make one square Rudolph — the one with the red nose — and shout “Don’t eat Rudolph!” It is a nice change if you play the Santa version on Christmas Eve and want something fresh on Christmas Day.
Team version. For a classroom or a large party, split into two teams. One team sends an eater while the other team picks the secret Santa, then swap. The team whose eater eats the most treats before hitting Santa wins the round. It turns a gentle family game into a proper contest.
Grown-ups version. The same game, but the treats are miniature mince pies, chocolate truffles, or small glasses of something festive for the adults. The rules do not change at all — and that is the point. Adults playing a children’s game with total seriousness is funny in a way that never gets old.
The advent version. Play one round each evening in the run-up to Christmas, using the grid as a countdown. The child who eats the most treats across the whole month wins a small prize on Christmas Eve. It takes two minutes a night and becomes a lovely little ritual.
Story version. Before the eater comes back into the room, the group makes up one sentence about why this particular Santa must not be eaten — he is the one carrying the presents, he is the one who lost his sleigh, he is the one who ate too many cookies already. It is a small addition, but it makes every round feel different.

Frequently Asked Questions
What age is Don’t Eat Santa best for? Ages four to ten are the sweet spot, but it genuinely works for anyone. Three-year-olds can play with help — an adult sits beside them and guides their hand. Teenagers will pretend they are too old for it and then demand to be the eater.
How many treats do I need? One per square per round. For a sixteen-square grid and six rounds, that is nearly a hundred small treats, so buy a large bag of wrapped sweets rather than individual packets. It sounds like a lot, but a round uses far fewer than the full grid, because the game ends the moment Santa is touched.
What if the eater refuses to eat a treat? Let them skip it. No child should be made to eat something they do not want. Just agree that a skipped square counts as used, and the eater moves on to another one. The game survives perfectly well.
Can I play it with food allergies in the house? Yes, and you should plan for it from the start. Use treats everyone can eat, or give the allergic child their own small bowl of safe treats and let them place those on the grid. The game is about the secret, not the specific sweet.
Does the eater get to keep the treats they ate? They have already eaten them, which is the point. The treats left on the grid at the end of a round can be shared out among the watchers, or saved for the next round.
Can I use this game at school or nursery? It is ideal for a classroom party. Use a grid of twelve squares, non-food treats like stickers on a few squares if you need to manage sugar, and play in small groups so every child gets a turn as the eater. Teachers tell us the secret-picking part is wonderful for practising whispering and turn-taking.
More Games and Activities for Christmas
Don’t Eat Santa is a free game you can make in ten minutes, but if you want a whole shelf of ready-made Christmas fun for the children, our shop bundles were made for exactly this.
Get the Christmas Games Bundle — $17 (regular $21): Christmas Games Bundle — 24 printable Christmas games in one download, including bingo, trivia, scavenger hunts, and more. Enough to fill every rainy afternoon of the Christmas holidays.
Get the Kid Activities Bundle — $11 (regular $14): Christmas Kid Activities Bundle — 14 printable Christmas activities for children, including colouring pages, activity books, word searches, and puzzles. Perfect for keeping little hands busy while the adults cook Christmas dinner.